We call to end the blame game in divorce proceeding by promoting the amicable solutions.

The current practice in divorce fuels cycle of blame on each other during proceedings. Such practice of law and legal system has completely denied the concept of “end of marriage with dignity”, however the model should have prioritized amicable separations and no-fault divorce but it promotes fosters a bitter and lifelong battle.

The existing divorce model follows a fault-based grounds such as adultery, desertion, or cruelty which requires trial to prove the allegation which essentially leads to prolonged and acrimonious legal battles that inflict immense emotional and financial distress, particularly on men and children. When young individuals are entangled in contentious legal disputes over failed relationships, it affects their personal development and lead to depression, ultimately affecting the nation’s growth.

“The divorce model, instead of promoting the amicable separations, the current system incentivizes blame games and encourages a culture of litigation which not only exacerbates existing tensions but also creates significant barriers to healing and moving forward.”, Kumar S Ratan Men’s and Child Rights Activist

This fault-based divorces typically run for average 4-6 years, often starting with criminal cases like “Dowry Harassment” against men. These cases are followed by multiple mediation sessions, frequently dominated by financial settlements. Such practices further erode the dignity of marriage dissolution and perpetuate a cycle of conflict.

The Proposed Models:

• No-Fault Divorce: to shift towards a no-fault divorce system, where the irretrievable breakdown of a marriage (IRBM) is sufficient grounds for separation, would allow couples to end their relationships with dignity and minimize the trauma associated with the process. This approach would prioritize the well-being of all parties involved, particularly children, by facilitating smoother transitions and reducing the potential for prolonged conflict.

• Prenuptial Agreements: Recognizing the evolving nature of modern relationships, the legal framework should accommodate Prenuptial Agreements. These agreements can help couples establish clear expectations regarding finances, assets, and responsibilities before marriage, reducing the potential for disputes during divorce proceedings.

Highlighting the Plight of Parents:

The current system often leaves parents, particularly fathers, feeling alienated from their children. Cases like that of Atul Subhas, who did not have the access to his child since the age of three months of the kid, and Alok Mittal case, who has only seen his child for a brief period 9-days, are tragically common. These heartbreaking situations highlight the urgent need for reforms that prioritize the best interests of children and ensure that both parents have meaningful roles in their lives.

Call to Action:

Lawmakers must recognize the limitations of the current divorce laws and take immediate steps to modernize the system. This includes:

• Introducing a no-fault divorce ground.
• Prioritizing the best interests of children in all divorce proceedings.
• Implementing measures to facilitate amicable settlements and reduce the need for lengthy court battles.
• Ensuring Joint parental rights and responsibilities.
• Recognizing and upholding the validity of Prenuptial Agreements.

By these reforms, India can create a divorce system that is more just, compassionate, and better equipped to support families in navigating the complexities of separation.

Petition for No-Fault Divorce in India: End the culture of Blame Game

No-fault divorce model offers separation without a cycle of blame-game.

To Whom It May Concern,

We urge the Indian Court, Ministry of Law and the Law Commission to enact legislation considering the no-fault model of divorce in India.

Introduction:

Family law should prioritize fairness, compassion, and efficiency, especially in cases of divorce. The legal system should not encourage a cycle of blame or force families into prolonged conflict.

Marriage is a significant commitment, but sometimes relationships break down irreparably. In today’s world, families cannot afford to spend years in legal battles. Many couples do not wish to blame each other; instead, they seek a respectful and dignified way to end their marriage, rather than getting caught in an endless cycle of accusations.

With the outdated and adversarial “fault-based” models current divorce model exacerbate conflict and prolong suffering. It’s time to modernize our approach to divorce and adopt a more humane and constructive system with “No-Fault Divorce” model.

Fill in your details to support the Campaign

[contact-form-7]

Divorce Model

Under the current model of divorce in India, couples are often forced into unnecessary conflict, blame, and lengthy legal battles that serve no one’s best interests and it become more worse when children are involved.

A No-Fault Divorce Model allows couples to dissolve their marriage without any blame, significantly reducing emotional distress, legal costs, and time-consuming litigation. Many progressive countries have already adopted this model, and it has been proven to promote more amicable separations, healthier co-parenting, and overall social well-being.

The Problem with Fault-Based Divorce

In fault-based divorce systems, one spouse have to prove the other’s fault for the breakdown of the marriage. This approach forces couples into an adversarial process that often includes:

• Blame and Accusation: Spouses must accuse each other of wrongdoing, such as adultery, abuse, abandonment, or cruelty. This fuels resentment, making amicable co-parenting and future communication incredibly difficult.
• Increased Conflict and Legal Battles: Proving fault requires extensive legal maneuvering, investigation, and emotionally charged courtroom battles. This significantly increases legal costs and prolongs the divorce process, adding unnecessary stress and financial strain on families.
• Invasion of Privacy: Deeply personal and often embarrassing details of the marriage are made public, causing further emotional distress and damage to reputations.
• Unequal Power Dynamics: The fault system can be weaponized, creating power imbalances where one spouse may feel pressured or intimidated into accepting unfavorable settlements to avoid public accusations or lengthy legal battles.
• Negative Impact on Children: Children are often caught in the middle of fault-finding disputes, witnessing their parents engage in bitter conflict, leading to emotional distress and instability.

The Solution: No-Fault Divorce

A No-Fault Divorce Model provides a more constructive and modern approach, recognizing that sometimes marriages break down irreparably, and neither party needs to be blamed.

Why No-Fault Divorce is the Right Solution

• Focus on Resolution, Not Blame: Divorce is treated as a personal matter, not a legal contest of who is “at fault.” The focus shifts to fair resolutions for finances, property division, and child custody, without requiring proof of fault.
• Reduced Conflict and Acrimony: Removing the need to prove fault significantly reduces hostility, fostering a more cooperative environment and encouraging amicable settlements and healthier co-parenting relationships.
• Simplified and More Efficient Process: No-fault divorce streamlines legal proceedings, reducing court time, legal fees, and emotional exhaustion. This allows individuals to move forward with their lives more quickly and with less financial and emotional burden.
• Protected Privacy: Personal details remain private, as the focus is on practical aspects of separation, rather than public airing of grievances.
• More Compassionate and Realistic Approach: No-fault divorce acknowledges reality—relationships can end without assigning blame. It promotes a respectful and dignified process during a difficult life transition.
• Potentially Reduces Domestic Violence Risk: In some cases, fault-based systems trap individuals in abusive relationships because proving fault could escalate conflict. No-fault divorce provides a safer and more accessible exit.

We urge policymakers to prioritize a legal framework that promotes:

• Compassion and Fairness: Treating divorcing couples with dignity and respect.
• Efficiency and Affordability: Streamlining the process and reducing financial burdens.
• Reduced Conflict: Minimizing animosity and promoting cooperation, especially when children are involved.
• Focus on the Future: Enabling individuals to move forward and rebuild their lives with less emotional and financial damage.

Join Us in Advocating for a More Humane Divorce System

Sign this petition to show your support for No-Fault Divorce and help create a fairer, more compassionate legal system. Together, we can end the culture of blame and conflict in divorce.

This post aim to explain the procedure of divorce in India under the Hindu Marriage Act in a question-and-answer FAQ format to make it easier to understand.

It takes several years to get a divorce because India has no provision for prenuptial agreements and does not recognize no-fault divorce. Hence, the only options available for parties that they either move with mutually agreed conditions to a divorce or to file for divorce based on the other’s fault and contest it.

1. Different Divorce Model

There are essentially 2 model, Fault -based and no-fault divorce model, but India has only concept of fault-based divorce model. Let’s see the comparison chart.

2. Types of Divorce

2.1 Mutual Consent Divorce :

When both parties agrees to separate and file the divorce application jointly. Below are the law related to mutual consented divorce:

-> Section 13(b) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
-> Section 28 Special Marriage Act, 1954
-> Section 32(B) of Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936
-> Section 10A of Indian Divorce Act, 1869 (for Christians)

2.2 Contested Divorce or Fault-Based Divorce

When One spouse seeks a divorce but other party is not interested.

So a contested divorce can be filed under on the grounds of cruelty, desertion, adultery, mental disorder and for other reasons. The different laws which deals are:

-> Section 13(1) & 13(2) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955
-> Section 27 of Special Marriage Act, 1954
-> Sections 30 & 32 of Parsi Marriage and Divorce Act, 1936
-> Sections 10 & 11 of Indian Divorce Act, 1869 (for Christians)

2.3 Customary Divorce

Customary divorce rarely used, which is recognized under personal laws for certain communities, provided that the customs are well-established and recognized by courts.

Section 29(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 protects the validity of customary divorces. Tribes, some rural communities, and specific religious groups follow their own customary divorce practices.

Q: Which type of divorce is faster?

A: Mutual consent divorces are granted in six months, making them faster than contested divorces.

Q: Why do contested divorces take a long time?

A: Contested divorces are based on the fault-based principle, meaning the applicant must prove the allegations. This requires an extensive trial process, which can take several years.

Q: What is an annulment of marriage?

A: An annulment declares a marriage legally void, but it is only possible if specific criteria are met and the petition is filed within one year of marriage.

• Section 10 of the Hindu Marriage Act deals with judicial separation, which allows spouses to live apart without dissolving the marriage. This is different from annulment. Something like child marriage is not allowed.
• Section 11 of the Hindu Marriage Act deals with void marriages, such as cases where a person is already married and has not obtained a divorce, or where the marriage violates prohibited relationships (e.g., sibling-like relationships as per customs).
• Section 12 of the Hindu Marriage Act deals with voidable marriages, where the validity of marriage is in question—such as cases involving fraud, coercion, unsound mind, or lack of valid consent. If no petition is filed within one year, the marriage is treated as valid. Something like marriying a person who is in a state of unsound mind like drugged.

3. Grounds for filing a contested divorce, Fault based divorce

Grounds for contested divorce

A man can seek divorce under various grounds, including:

• Cruelty: physical or mental harassment by the wife.
• Adultery: wife having an extramarital affair.
• Desertion: wife leaving without reasonable cause for a reasonable period.
• Mental Disorder: if the wife suffers from an critical mental illness which shows are incompetency to manage family responsibilty.
• Conversion: if the wife converts to another religion.
• Venereal Disease: if the wife suffers from an incurable contagious disease.

Q: What are the grounds for filing a contested divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act?

A: Common grounds include cruelty, desertion, adultery, conversion, mental disorder, and other legally recognized reasons.

Q: Since the adultery law has been nullified, is adultery still a ground for divorce in India?

A: Yes, adultery remains a ground for divorce under personal laws. The Supreme Court has clarified in various rulings that while adultery is no longer a criminal offense, it can still be a valid reason for seeking divorce.

Q: What constitutes cruelty as a ground for divorce?

A: Cruelty can be physical or mental and includes actions that cause significant distress, harassment, or harm to the spouse.

Q: What is desertion, and how does it apply to divorce?

A: Desertion occurs when one spouse abandons the other without reasonable cause for a legally specified period (typically two years under the Hindu Marriage Act).

Q: Can I get a divorce based on the Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage (IRBM) law?

A: While Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage can be grounds for divorce, it is not yet codified into law for lower courts to grant divorce on this basis. Currently, only the Supreme Court of India has the power to grant divorce on this ground, and the process can take 15-20 years in most cases.

4. How to File for Divorce in India

Q: Where do I file for divorce in India?

A: A divorce application can be filed only in the Family Court having jurisdiction over the marriage or residence of the spouses.

Q: What documents are required for a divorce petition?

A: Yes, essential documents includes:

• Proof of marriage (wedding invitation, photographs, or marriage certificate)
• Photographs of the couple
• Marriage certificate (if available)
• Address proof of both spouses
• Evidence supporting the grounds for divorce (e.g., messages, emails, medical reports, witness statements)

Q: How long does the divorce process typically take in India?

A: Mutual consent divorce: Typically takes a minimum of six months. While the Contested divorce (fault-based) can take several years due to legal proceedings and court trials.

Q: Is there a waiting period in a mutual consent divorce?

A: Yes, a mutual consent divorce involves three motions of hearing to allow time for settlement, ensure compliance with conditions like payment of permanent alimony, and finalize the case closure.

Q: Can the mandatory waiting period of one year in a mutual consent divorce be waived?

A: The Supreme Court has issued guidelines for waiving the waiting period in exceptional circumstances. However, this waiver is granted rarely and is subject to the court’s discretion.

Q: Do I need a lawyer to get a divorce?

A: While it is not legally mandatory, it is highly recommended to have a lawyer for legal representation and guidance.

Q: Can divorce be filed online?

A: No, divorce cannot be filed online. Both spouses must appear before the court to file the divorce petition and complete the necessary legal proceedings.

5. Can a husband avoid paying alimony?

Alimony is determined based on multiple factors, including:

• The financial status of both spouses
• The earning capacity of the wife (should be, but generally not considered)
• The duration of the marriage (should be, but generally not considered)
• The presence of children

A husband can contest alimony if:

• The wife is financially independent
• The wife has deliberately left her job to claim maintenance
• There is proof of misuse of maintenance laws

6. What legal rights do men have during divorce?

Men have several legal rights, including:

• The right to contest false allegations and demand proof
• The right to claim shared assets and property acquired during marriage
• The right to seek child custody
• The right to appeal in higher courts

7. How can men protect themselves before and during divorce proceedings?

To safeguard their interests, men should:

• Keep records of all communications and financial transactions
• Avoid impulsive actions that could be used against you in court
• Seek legal advice early and consult any Men’s Rights Group and lawyer
• Engage in mediation before opting for litigation
• File counter-cases if facing false allegations

8. Important Questions

Q: How much does a divorce cost in India?

A: The cost of a divorce in India depends on several factors:

• Alimony to wife in Mutual consent divorce: it depends on agreement between parties.
• Alimony to wife in Contested divorce: it depends on husband earnings, in general 5-10 year of husband’s income.
• Lawyer’s fees: Can range from ₹30,000 to several lakhs, depending on experience and complexity.
• Court fees and paperwork: Usually minimal but varies by state.

Q: Can a NRI file for divorce in India?

A: Yes if married wit Indian woman.

Q: Is a divorce obtained in another country valid in India?

A divorce granted in another country may or may not be recognized in India, depending on the circumstances:

Recognized in India if, the divorce is based on mutual consent and follows the principles of natural justice.

Not recognized in India if, The divorce was granted ex parte (i.e., one spouse was not present or did not contest). or if it violates Indian laws or public policy (e.g., if granted on grounds not recognized under Indian law) or violates other certain laws.

Legal Consideration:

• If the foreign divorce is not recognized, the couple is still legally married in India.
• A fresh divorce petition may be required to be filed in Indian court under Indian law.
• Consulting a family law expert is recommended before relying on a foreign divorce decree.

Divorce laws in India can be challenging for men due to inherent biases. It is essential for men to stay informed, gather evidence, and seek proper legal support to navigate these difficulties. If you need assistance, reach out to Men Helpline Organization for guidance and support.